Who Should We Eat? (2017) Board Game

Who Should We Eat? is a party game released in 2017 by Broadway Toys LTD. It is designed for 4-10 players, making it ideal for larger groups looking for a fun and engaging game night experience. The game revolves around the premise of being stranded on a deserted island with limited resources, forcing players to make difficult decisions about who to eat in order to survive.

Game Components of Who Should We Eat?

12 Character Cards

Over 100 Food, Sanity, Build, and Ghost Cards

9 Long Straws

1 Short Straw

1 Wooden Conch

1 Board and Markers to track Sanity, Food, and Raft Building[4>.

How To Setup Who Should We Eat?

To set up the game, players start by drawing character cards that define their backgrounds and personality abilities. The board is prepared to track sanity, food, and raft building progress. Each player is given a set of cards to begin with, and the game leader is determined.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Mechanics:

Card Drawing: Players draw cards to gather resources such as food, sanity, and materials for the raft.

Resource Management: Managing the scarce resources, especially food, is crucial.

Trials: Trials are held to decide which player will be sacrificed for food.

Knife Fights: Players can initiate knife fights to determine who dies instead.

Ghost Mechanic: Dead players return as ghosts to haunt the living, trying to drive them insane.

Objective:

Survivors: Build a raft to escape the island before all players die or go insane.

Ghosts: Prevent the survivors from escaping by driving them insane or reducing their numbers.

Player Experience

Players take on the roles of survivors on a deserted island after a plane crash. The game is lighthearted but involves significant social interaction and strategic decisions. Each round, players must contribute to the group’s survival by playing cards, managing resources, and deciding who to sacrifice for food. The game becomes increasingly challenging as resources dwindle and players turn into ghosts, adding an element of betrayal and tension.

Pros

Thematic Adherence: The game adheres well to its survival theme.

Social Interaction: Encourages strong social interaction and discussion among players.

Unique Mechanics: The ghost mechanic adds a unique twist to the game.

Cons

Randomness: The game is heavily reliant on random card draws, reducing strategic depth.

Lack of Tension: The decision-making process can feel too structured and lacks genuine tension.

Limited Strategy: The game is more about luck and less about strategic planning.

Personal Thoughts on Who Should We Eat?

Who Should We Eat? is best suited for gamers who enjoy lighthearted, social games and are fans of the TV show “Survivor.” While it offers a unique and engaging theme, the gameplay mechanics are not particularly complex or strategic. The game’s reliance on randomness and structured decision-making processes may deter players seeking deeper strategic games. However, for a fun, party-oriented experience with a twist of betrayal and survival, Who Should We Eat? can be an entertaining addition to your game collection.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.