The King’s Dilemma (2019) Board Game

The King’s Dilemma is a unique board game released in 2019 by Horrible Guild. Designed by Hjalmar Hach and Lorenzo Silva, this game falls under the categories of fantasy, negotiation, and political games. With its innovative gameplay mechanics and storytelling elements, it has gained popularity among board game enthusiasts.

Game Components of The King’s Dilemma

Player Screens: Each player has a screen to track their house’s agendas and resources.

Dilemma Deck: A deck of cards presenting various problems for the Council to resolve.

Resource Tracks: Tracks for influence, wealth, morale, welfare, knowledge, and stability.

Power Tokens: Used for voting and influencing decisions.

Agenda Cards: Secret and open agenda cards that determine player goals and scoring.

Kingdom Board: Where resources and stability are tracked, and stickers are applied to impact future games.

Envelopes: Containing new storylines and dilemmas to be added to the deck as the game progresses.

How To Setup The King’s Dilemma

To set up the game, each player selects a secret goal card and a house screen, which outlines their family agendas. The initial story deck is shuffled, and three dilemma cards are drawn from the 00 envelope to start the game. Players receive money and influence markers, which are kept hidden behind their screens. The kingdom board is set up with the resource tracks and stability marker.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Voting Mechanic: Players vote on dilemmas, using power tokens to influence the outcome.

Resource Management: Decisions affect the kingdom’s resources, impacting stability.

Legacy Elements: Each game adds new cards to the dilemma deck and applies stickers to the kingdom board, affecting future games.

Secret Agendas: Players have secret goals that align with their house’s interests.

Negotiation and Bribery: Players can pass on voting to gain power or become the Moderator in case of a tie.

Objective: Balance personal house goals with the overall well-being of the kingdom to achieve the best score.

Player Experience

Players take on the roles of various houses leading the government of the Kingdom of Ankist. Each round, they draw a dilemma card and must discuss, bargain, and vote on the decision. The game is highly interactive, with players needing to balance their own ambitions with the needs of the kingdom. Decisions have immediate and long-term consequences, adding a layer of complexity and strategy. The game’s narrative evolves through multiple playthroughs, offering a unique story each time.

Pros

Immersive Storytelling: The game features a deeply engaging narrative with branching storylines.

High Replayability: With an evolving dilemma deck and legacy elements, each playthrough is unique.

Interactive Gameplay: Players engage in intense negotiations and bargaining.

Strategic Depth: Balancing personal goals with kingdom stability requires careful planning.

Cons

Complex Rules: The game has a lengthy rulebook, which can be daunting for new players.

Unpredictability: The outcome of votes and the king’s death can be unpredictable, making long-term planning challenging.

Resource Management: Managing the kingdom’s resources can be intricate and requires careful attention.

Personal Thoughts on The King’s Dilemma

The King’s Dilemma is ideal for players who enjoy narrative-driven games, negotiation, and strategic decision-making. It is best suited for groups of 3-5 players aged 14 and above. The game’s complex mechanics and legacy elements make it a great choice for those looking for a game with high replay value and deep engagement. However, it may not be the best fit for casual gamers due to its intricate rules and the need for significant time commitment to fully appreciate the game’s depth.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.