Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders (1983) Board Game

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders is an expansion to the original Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective board game, which was released in in 1983. This expansion, released in 1983, adds new cases and mysteries for players to solve alongside the great detective Sherlock Holmes.

Game Components of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders

Case book: Contains the narrative and clues for the mystery.

Clue books: Provide additional information and leads.

Newspapers: Include news articles that might hold clues.

Map of London: Helps players navigate the city.

Character cards: Represent suspects, witnesses, and other individuals involved in the case.

Rulebook: Explains the setup and gameplay.

How To Setup Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders

To set up the game, players start by reading the introduction in the case book, which sets the scene for the mystery. They then receive the initial clues and begin their investigation. Players use the map of London to move around the city, visiting locations mentioned in the clues. Each location may yield more information from the clue books or newspapers.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Cooperative gameplay: Players work together to solve the mystery.

Investigation: Players gather clues by visiting locations and interviewing characters.

Deduction: Players use the clues to piece together the events of the crime.

Objective: Solve the mystery by identifying the perpetrator, motive, and other key details before the game ends.

Player Experience

In **Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders**, players take on the roles of detectives working to solve a complex murder mystery. The game is highly immersive, with detailed narratives and realistic settings that transport players to Victorian-era London. The cooperative nature of the game encourages teamwork and discussion among players as they share clues and theories.

Pros

Immersive storyline: Richly detailed case that mimics the style of Sherlock Holmes stories.

High replayability: Multiple paths and clues ensure different experiences each time.

Cooperative gameplay: Encourages teamwork and interaction among players.

Educational: Teaches critical thinking and deductive reasoning.

Cons

Complex setup: Requires some time to understand the rules and set up the game.

Long gameplay: Sessions can be lengthy, especially for new players.

Limited player count: Best with 1-8 players, but optimal with a smaller group.

Personal Thoughts on Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Mansion Murders

This game is ideal for fans of Sherlock Holmes, mystery enthusiasts, and anyone who enjoys cooperative board games. It’s a great choice for groups looking for a challenging, intellectually stimulating experience. However, it may not be the best fit for those seeking quick, lightweight games or competitive gameplay. The game’s depth and complexity make it a standout in the detective genre, offering hours of engaging and thought-provoking entertainment.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.