Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective is a game originally published by Sleuth Publications in 1981. It is based on a tabletop game-gamebook hybrid of the same name and features the fictional detective Sherlock Holmes, created by Arthur Conan Doyle. The game uses live actors and sets as the player controls Sherlock Holmes and his longtime partner Dr. Watson, trying to solve three separate crimes by visiting various locations, listening to the dialogue, reading the included mock London newspapers, and, when the player gets enough evidence, answering the judge’s questions. The game has since had multiple expansions and reprints.

Why is Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Popular?

The game is popular because it is considered one of the best mystery games ever made. It is unique in that it is not a traditional board game, but rather a game-book hybrid that requires players to read and solve puzzles to progress through the game. The game’s popularity has led to multiple sequels and adaptations, including a video game adaptation by ICOM Simulations.

Game Components of Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

Case Books: Containing detailed cases, each with its own story, leads, and solutions.

Newspapers: Authentic, period-style newspapers providing crucial clues.

Map of London: Aids players in navigating and plotting suspects’ movements.

London Directory: A resource for finding locations and contacts.

Informants: Cards that offer additional clues and leads.

Score Sheets: For tracking players’ progress and comparing with Sherlock’s solutions.

How To Setup Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

To set up the game, players first read the introduction to the case, which sets the scene and provides initial clues. Each player receives a copy of the case book, the map of London, and the London Directory. The newspapers and informants are made available as resources. Players decide on a lead investigator who will guide the group in deciding which leads to follow. There is no strict setup procedure; the game evolves as players delve into the case.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Cooperative Investigation: Players work together to solve mysteries by following leads, visiting locations, and gathering clues.

Logical Deduction: Players must piece together evidence and make deductions to solve the case.

Resource Management: Using newspapers, the directory, and informants to gather information.

Scoring: Players answer questions about the case and compare their score to Sherlock’s, with penalties for visiting more locations than necessary.

Game Objective: Solve the mystery by answering questions correctly and efficiently, aiming to match or exceed Sherlock’s score.

Player Experience

Players immerse themselves in the Victorian era, taking on the roles of the Baker Street Irregulars, a group of street urchins who assist Sherlock Holmes. The game requires careful planning, discussion, and logical thinking. Players must navigate through detailed cases, each presenting a unique set of challenges and clues. The atmosphere is rich and immersive, with authentic newspapers and a detailed map of London enhancing the experience.

Pros

Immersive Atmosphere: Richly detailed world of Victorian London.

Challenging Mysteries: Complex cases that require deductive reasoning.

High Replayability: Multiple cases and variables ensure different experiences each time.

Cooperative Gameplay: Encourages teamwork and discussion among players.

Authentic Resources: Newspapers and directories add to the realism.

Cons

Complex Setup: Although setup is straightforward, understanding the mechanics and navigating the cases can be overwhelming for new players.

Time-Consuming: Each case can take several hours to solve, requiring a significant time commitment.

High Reading Requirement: Players must read extensively to gather clues, which can be daunting.

Frustration with Scoring: Comparing scores to Sherlock’s can be demotivating if players feel they are far off.

Personal Thoughts on Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

**Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective** is ideal for fans of mystery and detective fiction, particularly those who enjoy the Sherlock Holmes series. It is a game that rewards patience, teamwork, and logical thinking. While it can be challenging and sometimes frustrating, the sense of accomplishment in solving a complex case is highly rewarding. This game is not for those looking for a quick, casual gaming experience but is perfect for groups or individuals who are willing to invest time and effort into unraveling intricate mysteries.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.