Sherlock (2011) Board Game – Board Game Guys

Sherlock is a board game designed by David Boniffacy and released in in 2011. It is a children’s game that is based on the popular character Sherlock Holmes from the novels by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The game involves memory and deduction skills as players work together to solve a mystery.

Game Components of Sherlock

Sherlock card

Set of cards with various objects, numbers, and arrows

Thick, high-quality cards to prevent damage

How To Setup Sherlock

To set up the game, remove the Sherlock card from the deck and set it aside. Shuffle the remaining cards and place eight of them face up in a circle, ensuring the arrows on each card are on the outside. The rest of the cards are placed face down in the center of the circle. Players are given about 30 seconds to memorize the objects on the face-up cards before they are flipped over.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Memory Mechanic: Players must remember the objects on the face-down cards.

Sequential Guessing: Each player’s turn involves guessing the object on a card next to the Sherlock card, which then directs them to another card.

Card Movement: The Sherlock card moves around the circle based on the number and arrow on the correctly guessed card.

Card Collection: When the Sherlock card lands on a card already face up, the player takes that card and a new one is drawn from the deck.

Game Objective: The first player to collect six cards wins.

Player Experience

Sherlock is designed to test players’ memory and recall abilities. The game is simple to learn but can be challenging, especially as players need to remember the objects on multiple cards. The game’s difficulty can be adjusted by adding or removing cards from the table, making it suitable for both young children and adults.

Pros

Adjustable Difficulty: Easy to make the game easier or harder by changing the number of cards.

High-Quality Components: The cards are thick and well-made.

Engaging Mechanics: The game adds a unique twist to traditional memory games by directing players to new cards based on their guesses.

Suitable for Various Ages: Enjoyable for both children and adults.

Cons

Luck Element: The game has a significant luck component, as some players may have to guess fewer cards to collect one.

Limited Replayability: While fun, the game’s reliance on memory means it can become repetitive after several plays.

Personal Thoughts on Sherlock

Sherlock is a great game for those who enjoy memory games and are looking for a simple yet engaging experience. It is particularly well-suited for families or groups with a mix of ages, as it can be adapted to different skill levels. However, players who prefer games with less luck and more strategy might find Sherlock less appealing. Overall, it’s an enjoyable game that can be played in a relatively short amount of time, making it a good addition to any game collection.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.