Box cover of the "Catan Histories: Settlers of America Trails to Rails" board game, featuring a vintage locomotive at a station with people in period clothing and a dusk sky with a bird flying in the background.
| | | | | | | | | |

Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails (2010)

ByMichail

Settlers of America: Trails to Rails

Catan Histories: Settlers of America
– Trails to Rails is a board game designed by Klaus Teuber and published by Mayfair Games in 2010. It is part of the Catan Histories line, which incorporates major themes from American history into a Catan framework. The game is set during the 19th century American westward expansion, where players take on the roles of settlers who travel west in search of fortune or fame. The game combines the rich historical backdrop of American westward expansion with the award-winning mechanics of Catan.

Why is Settlers of America: Trails to Rails Popular?

Settlers of America is popular because it combines the fun and strategy of Catan with a historical theme that is both educational and entertaining. The game has won numerous awards, including “Best Historical Board Game” at the 2010 Origins Awards. It is also significant because it incorporates major themes from American history into a Catan framework, making it a unique and engaging way to learn about American westward expansion.

Game Components of Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

  • Game board depicting the USA with a fixed layout
  • Resource markers (lumber, ore, grain, coal, cattle)
  • Gold tokens
  • Settler and city pieces
  • Rail and train pieces
  • Development cards
  • Number chits that move westward as the game progresses
  • Player tokens and markers

    How To Setup Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

    To set up the game, players start by placing the game board, which features a map of the USA. The number chits are placed on the board, with some of these chits designed to move westward as the game progresses to simulate the westward expansion of the USA. Each player chooses a color and takes the corresponding settler, city, and train pieces. The resource markers, gold tokens, and development cards are also distributed according to the rules. Players begin by building settlements on the East Coast, marking the start of their westward journey.

    Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

    Gameplay Mechanics

  • Resource Collection: Players collect resources (lumber, ore, grain, coal, cattle) based on the number chits and the settlements they have built.
  • Gold Compensation: If a player does not collect any resources on a turn, they receive a gold token, which can be traded for resources later.
  • Settler Movement: Players build settlers and move them to construct new settlements on the board.
  • Rail Building: Players build rail lines to connect their settlements and deliver goods to other players’ cities.
  • Development Cards: These cards provide various bonuses and special powers during the game.

    Game Objective

  • The objective is to build all of your settlements and cities, and then deliver the goods from these settlements to other players’ cities using the rail network.
  • The game is won by the player who successfully delivers all their goods.

    Player Experience

    **Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails** offers a unique blend of resource management and railroad delivery mechanics, making it a compelling spin on the original Settlers of Catan. The game is designed for 3-4 players and typically lasts about 2 hours. Players must balance resource collection, settler movement, and rail building to achieve the game’s objectives. The addition of gold tokens helps mitigate the randomness of resource collection, but the busy board layout can make it challenging to keep track of all the elements.

    Pros

  • New Mechanics: Introduces new and engaging mechanics such as settler movement and rail building.
  • Thematic Integration: The game’s theme of westward expansion is well-integrated into the mechanics.
  • Gold Compensation: Helps balance out the randomness of resource collection.
  • Family-Friendly: Suitable for players who enjoy strategy and are familiar with the Catan series.

    Cons

  • Busy Board: The board can become cluttered with various elements, making it hard to see what is happening.
  • Non-Modular Board: Unlike the original Catan, the board is fixed, which may reduce replayability.
  • Longer Gameplay: The game lasts about 2 hours, which is longer than the original Settlers of Catan.

    Personal Thoughts on Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

    This game is ideal for fans of the Settlers of Catan series who are looking for a new challenge and additional layers of strategy. While it retains many of the core mechanics of the original, the inclusion of rail building and goods delivery adds a fresh twist. However, for casual players of Settlers-style games, the original might still be a better choice due to its simpler and more streamlined gameplay. Overall, **Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails** is a solid addition to the Catan family, offering a rich and engaging gaming experience.

    We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. 

    • Michail, a seasoned tabletop enthusiast, dives headfirst into worlds of fantasy and strategy. Whether commanding a party of adventurers through perilous dungeons or engaging in tactical showdowns on the board, Michail is the maestro of the tabletop realm. Michail's gaming table is a realm where the clatter of dice and the shuffle of cards create a symphony of strategic chaos.

    Hobby: Miniature painting guru, turning pewter into masterpieces
    Preferred Game: Dungeons & Dragons, but always up for a board game brawl