Replay Baseball (1973) Board Game

Replay Baseball is a classic board game that was first released in 1973 by Replay Publishing. It is a sports simulation game that allows players to experience the excitement of baseball in a tabletop setting. The game has a dedicated fan base and has been praised for its attention to detail and realistic gameplay mechanics.

Game Components of Replay Baseball

Play Board: A color-coded foldout board with all necessary charts

Player Cards: Pre-cut cards for batters and pitchers, typically 24-30 cards per team

Dice: Three dice (red, white, and blue) for resolving game actions

Playing Field and Base-runner Markers: For tracking game progress

Score Sheets: For recording game statistics

Rare Plays and Rules Booklet: Detailed rules and rare play scenarios

Ballpark Cards: Optional 1d6 or 2d6 cards for varying ballpark effects

Tall Pitcher Cards: Optional taller cards for pitchers, available for some sets

How To Setup Replay Baseball

To set up Replay Baseball, start by organizing the player cards into their respective team stacks. Each team’s cards are rubber-banded together and include both batters and pitchers. Place the play board in the center of the playing area and ensure all necessary components, such as dice, markers, and score sheets, are within reach. Choose the season yearbook or team set you wish to play with and follow the instructions in the Rare Plays and Rules booklet to understand how to use the cards and charts effectively.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Dice Rolling: Use the three dice to determine the outcomes of player actions, such as batting, pitching, and fielding

Player Ratings: Utilize statistical ratings on player cards to influence game outcomes

Statistical Analysis: The game is designed to mimic real baseball through detailed statistical analysis

Game Objective: Manage your team to win games by making strategic decisions on batting, pitching, and fielding, aiming to score more runs than the opposing team.

Player Experience

Replay Baseball offers a immersive experience for baseball enthusiasts, allowing players to manage their teams with a blend of fast play and detailed strategy. The game feels like real baseball, with players needing to make critical decisions such as when to bring in a closer, how to handle bases-loaded situations, and whether to use a pinch-hitter. The game’s unique system of interaction between offense and defense adds a layer of realism and engagement.

Pros

Realistic Baseball Experience: The game closely simulates real baseball strategies and outcomes

Detailed Player Ratings: Enhances the realism with accurate statistical representations of players

Strategic Depth: Allows for complex decision-making similar to real baseball management

Community: Has a dedicated fan base with various resources and forums available

Cons

Complex Setup: Requires careful organization and understanding of the rules and components

Compatibility Issues: Later versions may not be fully compatible with older card sets

Component Quality: Some sets may have minor defects such as warping of pitcher cards or slight handling creases

Personal Thoughts on Replay Baseball

Replay Baseball is ideal for die-hard baseball fans who appreciate the strategic and statistical aspects of the game. It offers a unique blend of realism and engagement, making it a great choice for those who enjoy sports simulation games. The game’s complexity and depth ensure that it remains entertaining and challenging, even after multiple plays. However, it may not be the best fit for casual gamers due to its detailed setup and rules.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.