Pick Your Poison (2016) Board Game

Pick Your Poison is a humorous party game that was released in in 2016. Designed by Tony Pellerito and illustrated by Player Ten, this game is meant for 3 to 10 players, with the best experience being for 6 to 8 players. It falls into the category of card games and humor party games, with a runtime of 30 to 60 minutes and an age recommendation of 10 and up. The game revolves around voting and making difficult choices, leading to some funny and entertaining moments.

Game Components of Pick Your Poison

300+ Poison Cards: These cards contain bizarre and humorous “what would you rather” scenarios.

Game Mat: Used to organize the gameplay.

Voting Cards: A and B voting cards for players to choose their preferred poison.

Double Down Card: Allows players to double their points if they score, or lose the card if they don’t.

Judge Role: Rotates among players, with the judge selecting and elaborating on the poison cards.

How To Setup Pick Your Poison

To set up the game, lay out the game mat and distribute six poison cards, one A and B voting card, and one double down card to each player. The player whose birthday was most recent becomes the judge. The judge picks a poison card from their hand and places it face up on the “Card A” spot on the game mat. Other players then submit a poison card from their hand face down to the judge, aiming to create the most difficult decision when compared to Card A.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Select Card A: The judge selects a poison card and places it on the game mat.

Submit Cards: Other players submit their poison cards to the judge.

Select Card B: The judge reads the submitted cards aloud and chooses the one that is most comparable to Card A.

Clarify: Players ask the judge clarifying questions about the two poison cards.

Pick Your Poison: Players anonymously select which poison card they would rather do.

Reveal: Players reveal their choices, and points are tallied based on majority votes.

Scorekeeping: Points are awarded based on voting outcomes, with the goal of reaching 15 points first.

Player Experience

**Pick Your Poison** is designed to spark fun conversations and debates among players. The game encourages players to think creatively about absurd scenarios, leading to hilarious and often side-splitting moments. The interactive nature of the game, where players can ask clarifying questions and the judge can elaborate on the scenarios, adds to the humor and engagement.

Pros

Family-Friendly: The Family Edition is suitable for players aged 10 and above, making it a great game for family gatherings and mixed-age groups.

High Replayability: With over 300 scenario cards, the game offers thousands of possible combinations, ensuring a unique experience each time.

Encourages Conversations: The game fosters open discussions and helps players understand each other’s preferences and quirks.

Easy to Learn: Simple and straightforward rules make it easy for new players to join in.

Cons

Content Limitation: Some players might find the need for more cards to expand the variety of scenarios.

Not Suitable for Very Young Children: Due to the nature of the scenarios, it is recommended for players aged 10 and above.

Personal Thoughts on Pick Your Poison

**Pick Your Poison** is an excellent addition to any game collection, particularly for those who enjoy social interaction and humor. It is ideal for family gatherings, game nights with friends, and even as a fun icebreaker at parties. The game’s ability to be combined with an NSFW Edition or After Dark Edition makes it versatile for different audiences. Overall, it is a must-have for anyone looking to add some laughter and engaging conversations to their social events.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.