Alt text: Contents of the board game "Knights and Knaves" are displayed, including the game box with medieval-themed artwork, various game components such as tiles and counters in plastic bags, instruction sheets, and a colorful map with different territories marked.
| | | | | | | | |

Knights and Knaves (2016)

ByMichail

Knights and Knaves

“Knights and Knaves” is a type of logic puzzle where some characters can only answer questions truthfully, and others only falsely. The game was first published in 1979 by Nimrod Game Development. The concept of Knights and Knaves has been adapted into various board games, such as “A Game of Knights and Knaves: Fire and Ice 2nd Edition,” which allows players to recreate historical and fantastical battles and campaigns set in different worlds.

Why is Knights and Knaves Popular?

The game is popular because it challenges players’ problem-solving skills and logical thinking. It requires players to pay close attention to the statements made by the characters and to use deductive reasoning to determine the truthfulness of their answers. This helps players develop their logical reasoning and critical thinking abilities, which are essential skills in various aspects of life.

Game Components of Knights and Knaves

  • Map:** Showing the Empire’s 68 realms, with 60 realms displayed and eight others including extinct realms and the Empire itself.
  • Counters:** Representing mercenaries, troops, and nobles.
  • Titles and Realms:** Various titles such as Emperor, Patriarch, Kings, and Lord Mayors, along with realms like The Aylemark, The League of Urf Durfal, and more.
  • Optional Rules:** Single combat, mutinous mercenaries, assassination, conspiracy, plague, special events, and magic.

    How To Setup Knights and Knaves

    To set up the game, players begin by determining the initial distribution of realms and titles. Each player selects a noble and starts with a set of realms and troops. The map is laid out to show the Empire’s political divisions, and players place their counters accordingly. The game rules outline the sequence of play, starting with the current Emperor, followed by the Patriarch, then other titles in order of precedence.

    Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

  • Soldiery Payment:** Players pay for the mercenary companies they control.
  • Movement and Combat:** Players move troops through realms with permission from the realm’s owner; unauthorized movement constitutes an attack.
  • Taxation:** Players receive taxes from their realms, with optional rules for tax gouging and revolts.
  • Elections:** Elections are held for vacant offices like Emperor and Patriarch if necessary.
  • Game Objective:** Players aim to gain wealth, power, and rank by building cohesive kingdoms within the Empire. Victory is determined in three categories: Most Powerful (most troops), Most Noble (most titles), and Richest.

    Player Experience

    In “Knights and Knaves,” players are immersed in a medieval setting where they navigate complex relationships between lords and vassals. The game encourages negotiation, strategic planning, and tactical decisions. Players must manage their resources, make alliances, and engage in combat to expand their influence. The game’s dynamic nature, with many optional rules, allows for infinite variations, keeping each game unique and engaging.

    Pros

  • High Replayability:** Numerous optional rules and variations ensure no two games are the same.
  • Strategic Depth:** Players must balance resource management, diplomacy, and military strategy.
  • Negotiation Encouraged:** Players can negotiate anything within the game’s framework, adding a social element.
  • Rich Medieval Setting:** The game is set in a detailed medieval environment with colorful realm names and titles.

    Cons

  • Complex Rules:** The game has a considerable number of rules, which can be overwhelming for new players.
  • Long Playtime:** Games typically last one and a half to two hours, which may be too long for some players.
  • Large Number of Players:** While it supports 4 to 60 players, managing such a large group can be challenging.

    Personal Thoughts on Knights and Knaves

    “Knights and Knaves” is ideal for players who enjoy complex strategy games with a strong social and negotiation component. It is suited for those interested in medieval settings and who appreciate games with high replayability. However, due to its complexity and lengthy playtime, it may not be the best fit for casual or new board game enthusiasts. This game is perfect for experienced players looking for a deep and engaging experience.

    We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. 

    • Michail, a seasoned tabletop enthusiast, dives headfirst into worlds of fantasy and strategy. Whether commanding a party of adventurers through perilous dungeons or engaging in tactical showdowns on the board, Michail is the maestro of the tabletop realm. Michail's gaming table is a realm where the clatter of dice and the shuffle of cards create a symphony of strategic chaos.

    Hobby: Miniature painting guru, turning pewter into masterpieces
    Preferred Game: Dungeons & Dragons, but always up for a board game brawl