Great Western Trail: Second Edition (2021) Board Game

Great Western Trail: Second Edition is a revised version of the original board game released in in 2021. Designed by Alexander Pfister and published by eggertspiele, this game takes players on a journey through the American West as they herd cattle, construct buildings, and deliver goods to various cities along the trail.

Game Components of Great Western Trail: Second Edition

Player Boards: Dual-layered boards for key areas, with some components adjustable for different player counts.

Worker Tiles: Cowboys, Builders, and Engineers to aid in various tasks.

Hazard Tiles: Flood, drought, and rockfall tiles that affect gameplay.

Outlaw Tiles: Placed on the board to increase movement costs.

Cattle Cards: Representing different types of cattle for delivery.

Neutral Building Tiles: Randomly placed to create varying actions and opportunities.

Job Market Token: Tracks the game’s progression.

Exchange Tokens: Originally from the Rails to the North expansion, now included in the base game.

How To Setup Great Western Trail: Second Edition

To set up the game, start by placing the board in the middle of the table. Shuffle and randomly place the nine station master tiles and seven neutral building tiles on their corresponding spaces. Separate the worker, hazard, and outlaw tiles according to their numbers and place them in designated bags. Draw tiles from the first bag and place them on the board, ensuring Outlaw and Hazard tiles are placed in the lowest numbered empty spaces. Finally, set up the job market area and player boards according to the player count.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Player Movement: Move your herder to different locations on the road network, avoiding opponents, Outlaws, and Hazards.

Action Performance: Perform actions based on the location tile or auxiliary actions on your personal display.

Hiring Workers: Hire Cowboys, Builders, and Engineers to enhance your abilities.

Cattle Acquisition: Buy and upgrade cattle cards to increase their value.

Building Placement: Place private buildings to gain additional actions.

Objective Cards: Gain objective cards to unlock new abilities and score points.

Delivery: Deliver cattle to Kansas City and optionally to New York for profit and victory points.

Player Experience

Great Western Trail: Second Edition offers a complex yet engaging experience, with multiple paths to achieving victory. Players must strategically plan their cattle drives, manage resources, and outmaneuver opponents. The game includes deck building, hand management, and ownership mechanics, making each playthrough unique due to the variable setup and random tile placements.

Pros

Deep Strategy: Offers a rich strategic experience with multiple layers of gameplay.

High Replayability: Variable setup and random tile placements ensure varied gameplay experiences.

Solo Mode: Includes a solo mode for players who prefer solo adventures.

Immersive Theme: Engaging 19th century American West theme that enhances the gameplay experience.

Cons

Complex Setup: Initial setup can be time-consuming and complex.

Component Quality: Some players find the new component quality, such as the flimsy cards and top-heavy meeples, to be disappointing.

Insert Issues: The game insert is often criticized for being impractical.

Personal Thoughts on Great Western Trail: Second Edition

Great Western Trail: Second Edition is ideal for fans of strategic board games who appreciate a deep, immersive experience. It is suited for players aged 12 and above, and its playtime of 75-150 minutes makes it a substantial commitment but a rewarding one. The game’s complexity and multiple mechanics make it a favorite among experienced board game enthusiasts, but it may not be the best choice for casual or new players due to its steep learning curve.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.