Great Western Trail (2016) – Board Game Guys

Great Western Trail

Great Western Trail is a board game designed by Alexander Pfister for two to four players, which was published in 2017 by Eggertspiele. It is a complex and strategic ‘Eurogame’, loosely themed on the American frontier and the original Great Western Cattle Trail, in which players engage in the transportation of cattle. A second edition was published in 2021, for one to four players.

Why is Great Western Trail Popular?

Great Western Trail is a popular game due to its unique theme, complex Gameplay Mechanics of Great Western Trail, and strategic depth. It has received critical acclaim and won several awards, including the Deutscher Spielepreis in 2017. The game is significant for its contribution to the board game industry and its popularity among board game enthusiasts.

Game Components of Great Western Trail

Components: High-quality board, cards, and cardboard components, though player boards are somewhat thin and prone to damage.

Include: Player boards, building tiles, deck of cow cards, neutral buildings, hazards, and tokens.

Art and Design: Colorful art style and durable components, except for the thin player boards.

How To Setup Great Western Trail

Setting up Great Western Trail involves several key steps:

Each player starts with a hand of four cow cards and a personal player board.

The main board is set up with neutral buildings and hazards along the trail.

The deck of cow cards and other resources are prepared for player use.

The game includes dynamic setup elements, such as the random placement of buildings and the draw of tiles and cards, which ensures each game is unique.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Mechanics: Deck-building, hand management, resource management, and ownership.

Objective: Players aim to lead their herd of cattle from Texas to Kansas City, managing resources, recruiting cowboys, and improving their ranch to maximize points.

Gameplay: Players move along the trail, stopping at buildings to perform actions such as acquiring more cows, hiring people, and building new structures. The game ends when all players reach Kansas City and sell their cattle, with points awarded for various achievements.

Player Experience

Great Western Trail offers a deep and strategic experience with multiple paths to victory. Players must adapt to the dynamic board state and make strategic decisions about resource and hand management. While the game can feel somewhat solitary, especially in two-player games, it becomes more interactive with three or four players. The game’s engine-building mechanism and the need to plan several moves in advance create a challenging and rewarding experience.

Pros

Strategic Depth: Many strategic paths to explore, making each game unique and challenging.

Dynamic Setup: Random board state and draw elements ensure high replayability.

Component Quality: High-quality components, except for the thin player boards.

Theme Integration: The game’s theme is well-integrated with its mechanics, providing an immersive experience.

Cons

Steep Learning Curve: Lots of iconography to learn and remember.

Thin Player Boards: Prone to damage due to thin cardboard.

Limited Interaction in 2-Player Games: The game feels more solitary with two players, though it improves with more players.

Personal Thoughts on Great Western Trail

Great Western Trail is ideal for fans of complex Eurogames who enjoy deep strategic gameplay and multiple paths to victory. It is particularly suited for players who appreciate games with high replayability and dynamic setups. While it may not be the best choice for those looking for high player interaction in two-player games, it excels with three or four players. If you’re into games like Terraforming Mars, Concordia, or Everdell, you’ll likely find Great Western Trail to be a compelling addition to your collection.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.