Deal or Duel (2017) Board Game

Deal or Duel is a board game released in 2017 that is centered around the American Revolutionary War. It combines elements of strategy, negotiation, and political maneuvering, making it an engaging and educational experience for players. The game allows 2-6 players to compete against each other in a battle of wits and tactics, with the ultimate goal of emerging victorious in the war.

Game Components of Deal or Duel

54 Historical Face Cards: Featuring various founding fathers and mothers.

120 Action Cards: For various game actions and events.

40 Hamilton Cards: Special cards that can significantly impact the game.

$3,500 Colonial Cash: The in-game currency.

Face Card Roster Scroll: For tracking player progress.

Playing Mat: For organizing the game area.

How To Setup Deal or Duel

To set up the game, players first need to shuffle and distribute the cards. Each player starts with a set amount of Colonial Cash and a few face cards. The playing mat is used to organize the different card types and game areas, such as the Debtor’s Prison and the Hamilton card slot. While the provided mat is helpful, it can be a bit small, leading to some cards overlapping during dueling.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Strategy and Sabotage: Players use action cards to outmaneuver each other.

Greed and Dueling: Accumulate Colonial Cash while navigating random events and challenges.

Game Objective: The goal is to accumulate all the Colonial Cash or be the last player standing, surviving the financial turmoil and duels.

Player Experience

Players have reported a fun and challenging experience with Deal or Duel. The game is suitable for 2-6 players, aged 10 and above, and typically lasts around two hours. While the rules can be a bit unclear in some areas, such as handling discard piles and unplayable cards, these issues are minor and can be worked around. The game’s historical flavor, with trivia and narratives on the cards, adds an educational and entertaining layer to the gameplay.

Pros

Engaging Strategy: Combines financial management with strategic card play.

Historical Flavor: Incorporates historical figures and events, making it educational.

Replayability: Various card combinations ensure different experiences each time.

Social Interaction: Suitable for a group of 2-6 players, promoting social interaction and competition.

Cons

Complex Rules: Some rules are ambiguous, such as handling discard piles and unplayable cards.

Small Playing Mat: The provided mat can be too small for proper card placement during dueling.

Learning Curve: Not suitable for casual gamers; requires some experience with strategic games.

Personal Thoughts on Deal or Duel

Deal or Duel is perfect for fans of Alexander Hamilton, history enthusiasts, and those who enjoy strategic card games. It is not a game for casual gamers, as it requires some level of experience with games like Settlers of Catan or Ticket to Ride. However, once understood, it offers a rich and engaging gaming experience that combines strategy, history, and social interaction. If you’re looking for a game that challenges and entertains, Deal or Duel is a great choice.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.