Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails (2010) Board Game

Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails is a standalone game in the Catan Histories series, which reimagines the classic Catan gameplay in different historical settings. In this particular version, players take on the roles of 19th-century settlers in America, building railroads and establishing settlements across the country. Designed by Klaus Teuber and published by Mayfair Games in 2010, this game combines elements of exploration, negotiation, and strategic resource management.

Game Components of Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

Game board featuring a map of the young United States

Resource cards (lumber, ore, grain, coal, cattle)

Gold tokens

Settler tokens

Train tokens

Rail segments

Development cards

City tokens

Outlaw token

Dice

How To Setup Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

To set up the game, players first place the game board, which is a fixed map of the United States. All settlements are initially built on the East Coast. Resource numbers are placed on the board, with some numbers moving westward as the game progresses. Each player chooses their color and places their two starting settlements and two roads on the board. Players also receive a starting hand of resource cards and gold tokens. The game is ready to begin once all components are distributed and the board is fully set up.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Resource Management: Players collect resources (lumber, ore, grain, coal, cattle) based on the roll of two dice. If a player earns no resources, they receive a gold token instead.

Settlement and City Building: Players must build settlers to move and construct new settlements and cities.

Railroad Building: Players build rail segments to connect their cities and other players’ cities.

Train Movement: Trains are used to deliver goods to other players’ cities.

Development Cards: These cards provide special bonuses and powers during the game.

Game Objective: The goal is to build all of your cities and deliver all of your goods by rail to other players’ cities.

Player Experience

Playing **Settlers of America – Trails to Rails** offers a unique blend of strategic resource management and railroad building. The game starts with players building settlements on the East Coast and gradually moving westward, mirroring the historical westward expansion of the United States. The addition of gold tokens helps balance out the randomness of resource collection. However, the game can feel longer than the original Catan, lasting about two hours, and the board can become cluttered with various components.

Pros

Combines classic Catan mechanics with engaging railroad-building and goods delivery.

Introduces gold tokens to mitigate the luck of the dice rolls.

Historical theme adds a rich layer of immersion.

Encourages strategic thinking in resource management and railroad construction.

Cons

The game can be quite long, lasting about two hours.

The board becomes cluttered with multiple components, making it hard to keep track of everything.

The fixed board layout, unlike the modular board of the original Catan, reduces variability between games.

Personal Thoughts on Catan Histories: Settlers of America – Trails to Rails

This game is ideal for fans of the Settlers of Catan series who are looking for a fresh twist on the classic gameplay. It is particularly suited for those who enjoy strategic planning and historical themes. While it may not be the best choice for casual players due to its complexity and length, it offers a rewarding experience for those willing to invest the time. If you don’t mind a longer game and enjoy the combination of resource management and railroad building, **Settlers of America – Trails to Rails** is a great addition to your board game collection.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.