Blue vs. Gray (1999) Board Game

Blue vs. Gray is a wargame based on the American Civil War, designed by Evan Jones and published by GMT Games in in 1999. The game allows players to take on the roles of either the Union (Blue) or the Confederacy (Gray) as they fight in various battles of the Civil War.

Game Components of Blue vs. Gray

Map Cards: These cards are used to build an accurate map of America as the game progresses, expanding towards the Southern player.

Combat Cards: Used for resolving battles.

Supply Cards: Essential for maintaining the players’ armies.

Leadership Cards: Representing historical figures like Stonewall Jackson and Ulysses S. Grant.

Deployment Cards: For dividing and organizing troops into different theaters (Eastern and Western).

How To Setup Blue vs. Gray

To set up the game, start by placing the AT START Map Cards in the center of the play area, ensuring the map’s printing faces the Southern player. Deploy the initial cards according to the specific theaters (Eastern and Western). Each player sets up their cadre, which includes commanders and divisions, and draws an initial hand of cards. The board layout is crucial, with specific notches and areas designated for naval units and other deployments.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Turn Sequence: Consists of Draw/Replace, Deploy/Move, Combat, Reorganization, and Regroup phases.

Game Objective:

USA: Must occupy vital centers of the South to win.

CSA: Must invade the North or survive the Yankee onslaught.

Victory Conditions: Include various scenarios such as capturing Washington, British intervention, or achieving specific objectives by the 1864 Elections.

Theater Management: Players must manage their forces across the Eastern and Western theaters, including naval units and supply lines.

Player Experience

Playing **Blue vs. Gray** requires strategic thinking and historical insight. Players need to balance resource management, troop deployment, and combat tactics to achieve their objectives. The game encourages continuous pressure and strategic planning, especially for the Northern player, who must leverage their vast resources effectively. For the Southern player, defending key locations and timing counterattacks are crucial.

Pros

Historical Accuracy: The game incorporates many historical elements and figures, making it appealing to history buffs.

Strategic Depth: Offers a complex and engaging gameplay experience with multiple victory conditions.

Replayability: Different card draws and player strategies ensure each game is unique.

Cons

Complexity: The game has a steep learning curve due to its intricate rules and multiple phases.

Setup Time: Setting up the game can be time-consuming, especially for new players.

Length: Games can be lengthy, requiring several hours to complete.

Personal Thoughts on Blue vs. Gray

**Blue vs. Gray** is ideal for those interested in historical wargames and strategy. It is particularly suited for players who enjoy complex gameplay mechanics and are willing to invest time in learning the rules. The game’s depth and historical context make it a compelling choice for Civil War enthusiasts and serious board game strategists. However, it may not be the best fit for casual gamers due to its complexity and lengthy gameplay.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.