Who Stole the Cookie? (2014) Board Game

Who Stole the Cookie?’ is a party game designed by Christy Sanderson and published in in 2014. The game is a mix of deduction and memory, requiring players to use their wits to figure out who the cookie thief is. With simple rules and quick gameplay, it is a great choice for game nights and gatherings with friends and family.

Game Components of Who Stole the Cookie?

3 cookie cards

15 crumb cards

Minimal packaging including a sleeve and instructions

How To Setup Who Stole the Cookie?

To set up the game, shuffle 2-3 cookie cards with 6-15 crumb cards depending on the number of players. Place two cards face-down in the center of the table and deal two cards to each player. Each player can secretly look at only one of their cards before the game begins.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Peek: Look at any one face-down card.

Switch: Switch the position of any two cards.

Shuffle: Have someone shuffle the two cards in front of you, then look at one of them.

Declare: Declare you know where two cookies are, choosing a card that you have or a card in the center of the table only if you can choose both of them. If correct, you win; if not, you are removed from the game.

The objective is to find two cookies, as having just one is not enough.

Player Experience

**Who Stole the Cookie?** is a simple yet engaging game of deduction and bluffing. Players must use their observational skills and strategic thinking to figure out where the cookies are hidden. The game is enjoyable with both kids and adults, though it is more challenging and enjoyable with adults due to the need for maintaining a poker face and practicing deduction skills. Younger players can still benefit from playing, as it helps them develop these skills.

Pros

Portable and Affordable: The game is compact, fitting in a small sleeve, and is priced at $5.99.

Quick Playtime: Games last about 10 minutes, making it an excellent on-the-go game.

Develops Deduction Skills: Encourages players to use logic and observation.

Fun for Various Ages: While designed for 13+, it can be played with younger children to help them develop game skills.

Cons

Simple Mechanics: Some players might find the rules and gameplay too straightforward.

Limited Depth: It lacks the complexity of deeper games like Good Cop Bad Cop or Mascarade.

Cookie Rules Can Be Clunky: The necessity of having two cookies if they are in front of you or in the center can feel a bit awkward.

Personal Thoughts on Who Stole the Cookie?

**Who Stole the Cookie?** is perfect for those looking for a light, fun, and quick game to add to their collection. It’s ideal for families who want to engage in a game that’s easy to learn but still challenging enough to be enjoyable. The game’s portability and affordability make it a great addition to any gaming arsenal, especially for those who appreciate deduction and bluffing mechanics. While it may not replace more complex games, it serves well as a filler game or an introduction to more strategic gameplay for younger players.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.