Brother against Brother (1997) Board Game

Brother against Brother is a board game released in 1997 by Stratagem Publications LTD. It is a two-player game set during the American Civil War, focusing on tactical combat and strategic decision-making. The game has a runtime of 180 minutes and is recommended for players aged 14 and up.

Game Components of Brother against Brother

Rulebook

2 player aids

216 Counters representing infantry, cavalry, artillery, leaders, and markers

16 page campaign scenario booklet

4 11×17 inch full-color maps

How To Setup Brother against Brother

Begin by choosing a scenario from the campaign scenario booklet.

Set up the maps and place the counters according to the scenario’s instructions.

Each player selects a side to play as.

Familiarize yourself with the rules and gameplay mechanics.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Players take turns moving their units, engaging in combat, and trying to achieve specific objectives outlined in each scenario. Dice rolling is a key mechanism in resolving combat and determining outcomes.

Player Experience

Pros:

Detailed historical accuracy in unit representation and scenarios

Strategic depth and decision-making opportunities

Immersive gameplay experience for history enthusiasts

Cons:

Steep learning curve for new players

Lengthy runtime may not be suitable for all players

Limited replayability with set scenarios

Personal Thoughts on Brother against Brother

Brother against Brother offers a deep dive into the American Civil War, providing historical context and strategic challenges for players. The game’s components are well-designed, and the attention to detail in unit representation is commendable. However, the game’s niche appeal may limit its audience, and the pricing for both new and used copies can be a deterrent for casual gamers.

Overall, Brother against Brother is worth your time if you are a history buff or enjoy tactical wargames with a historical theme. For those looking for alternatives, games like Battle Cry and Memoir ’44 offer similar gameplay experiences in different historical settings. Players who prefer shorter game sessions or lighter gameplay mechanics may want to skip Brother against Brother.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.