Sherlock Holmes: The Challenge Of Irene Adler (2016) Board Game

Sherlock Holmes: The Challenge Of Irene Adler is a board game released in 2016 by Makaka Editions. It is part of the Sherlock Holmes Series: Graphic Novel Adventures, designed by Cédric Asna. The game is based on the iconic detective Sherlock Holmes and his arch-nemesis Irene Adler.

Game Components of Sherlock Holmes: The Challenge Of Irene Adler

Game Book: Contains the mysteries and puzzles to be solved.

Contact Lists: Separate lists for Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler.

Question and Answer System: A set of questions with multiple-choice answers.

Rules: Instructions for setting up and playing the game.

How To Setup Sherlock Holmes: The Challenge Of Irene Adler

Setting up the game is relatively straightforward and quick. Players choose to play as either Sherlock Holmes or Irene Adler, each having their own set of contacts. The game book provides the necessary instructions and the mysteries to be solved. The setup time is almost none, making it easy to jump into the game immediately.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Solo or Competitive Play: Players can play solo or head-to-head, taking on the roles of Sherlock Holmes or Irene Adler.

Mystery Solving: The objective is to solve a pair of mysteries by piecing together clues.

Contact System: Players use contacts to gather information.

Question and Answer System: Players answer questions based on the clues they gather, with each question having multiple-choice options.

Competitive Element: In the competitive mode, players compete to solve the mysteries first.

Player Experience

The game offers a mixed experience for players. While it starts with excitement and the promise of intriguing mysteries, it often falls flat due to several design issues. Players may find the quality of the mysteries disappointing, and the immediate revelation of solutions can reduce the game’s replay value. The game’s design allows for quick setup and play, but the engagement level can be low, especially after the initial playthrough.

Pros

Easy Setup: Almost no setup time required.

Solo and Competitive Modes: Offers flexibility in gameplay.

Historical Theme: Set in Victorian London, adding to the Sherlock Holmes ambiance.

Quick Play: Each play session lasts about 1 hour.

Cons

Revealed Solutions: Solutions are given away immediately, reducing replay value.

Lack of Cohesive Mysteries: Mysteries may not be as engaging or cohesive as expected.

Minor Typos and Confusions: Some minor errors in the game book can be annoying.

Difficult Puzzles: Some puzzles are extremely difficult or have multiple solutions that appear correct but are not.

Personal Thoughts on Sherlock Holmes: The Challenge Of Irene Adler

This game is suited for fans of the Sherlock Holmes series and those who enjoy solo or competitive mystery-solving games. However, due to its design flaws, particularly the immediate revelation of solutions, it may not offer long-term engagement. It’s best for those looking for a quick, casual mystery-solving experience rather than a deeply immersive and challenging game. Despite its shortcomings, it can still provide an enjoyable hour of detective work, especially for those who appreciate the historical and thematic elements of the Sherlock Holmes universe.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.