Mystery (2016) Board Game – Board Game Guys

Mystery is a graphic novel adventure board game released in 2016 by Makaka Editions. Designed by Cédric Asna and illustrated by Stivo, this game is part of the Graphic Novel Adventures series and is themed around superheroes in the city of Chicago, Illinois, USA. It is a solitaire game, meaning it is designed for one player only.

Game Components of Whodunit

Game board depicting a mansion

Detective sheets for recording clues and alibis

Suspect, motive, weapon, and scene of the crime cards

Player tokens

Clue cards

How To Setup Whodunit

To set up the game, each player chooses a token and places it at the starting point on the board. Each player receives a detective sheet to record clues and alibis. The objective is to solve the murder by identifying the suspect, motive, weapon, and scene of the crime.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Movement: Players move through the mansion to gather clues.

Clue Collection: Players collect and record clues on their detective sheets.

Alibis: Players pursue alibis to eliminate suspects, weapons, and motives.

Objective: Solve the four key questions: What was the motive? Where was the scene of the crime? What was the murder weapon? Which suspect is guilty?

Player Experience

Players experience a thrilling mystery-solving adventure as they navigate the mansion, collect clues, and eliminate possibilities. The game encourages strategic thinking and deductive reasoning.

Pros

Engaging Theme: The game is set in a rich, mysterious environment that fans of detective stories will enjoy.

Interactive: Players interact with each other’s alibis, adding a social element.

Challenging: The game requires careful observation and deduction to solve the mystery.

Cons

Complexity: The game can be complex for new players due to the multiple variables (suspect, motive, weapon, scene).

Outdated: As a game from 1985, the components and design may feel outdated compared to modern games.

Personal Thoughts on Whodunit

Whodunit is ideal for fans of mystery and detective stories, particularly those who enjoy games like Clue. It is a great option for groups of friends or family looking to engage in a cooperative yet competitive puzzle-solving experience. However, due to its age, it may not appeal as strongly to players accustomed to more modern game mechanics and components.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.