Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars (2020) Board Game

Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars is a board game released in 2020 by designer Bruce Whitehill. It falls under the categories of Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Party Game, and Puzzle. The game is designed for 1-99 players, making it suitable for large gatherings or parties. Players will need to use their deduction skills and role-playing abilities to solve the mystery at Underwood Cellars.

Game Components of Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

50+ pieces of evidence: Includes victim and suspect photos, crime scene photos, newspaper articles, witness statements, written letters, the detective’s notebook, and a timeline.

Realistic physical and online evidence: Players have access to a variety of documents and images to build their case.

Folders and case files: The game is presented in a sturdy, file-folder-like box containing two main folders with all the evidence.

How To Setup Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

To set up the game, players simply need to open the case file box and begin reviewing the evidence. The game does not require complex setup; players can immediately dive into reading and analyzing the provided documents and photos.

Gameplay Mechanics and Game Objective

Detective role-playing: Players take on the role of detectives to solve the murder of winemaker Cary Underwood.

Evidence analysis: Players must pore over physical and online evidence to build their case.

Identify motive, means, and opportunity: The objective is to list suspects and determine which one had the motive, means, and opportunity to commit the crime.

Solo or group play: The game can be played by one or more players, making it suitable for individual sleuths or group gatherings.

Player Experience

Players are immersed in a real-life-like investigation, where they must carefully read and analyze the provided evidence to piece together the events surrounding Cary Underwood’s murder. The game encourages critical thinking and deductive reasoning. However, some players have noted that the game can be completed relatively quickly and may lack additional gameplay elements beyond reading and deducing the killer’s identity.

Pros

Extensive and realistic evidence: The game includes a wide range of realistic documents and photos, enhancing the investigative experience.

Engaging storyline: The case of Cary Underwood’s murder in Napa Valley is intriguing and keeps players engaged.

Simple setup: The game is easy to start, with no complex rules or setup required.

Cons

Quick completion: Some players have found that the game can be solved too quickly, lacking additional gameplay elements.

Lack of drama and intrigue: The characters and storyline, while engaging, are somewhat straightforward and lack complex relationships or additional drama.

Personal Thoughts on Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

This game is ideal for fans of crime novels, cold-case TV shows, and escape room games. It provides a unique and immersive experience, particularly suited for dinner parties or individual puzzle enthusiasts. While it may be too straightforward for some, the game’s realism and extensive evidence make it a compelling choice for those who enjoy detective work and solving mysteries. However, those seeking more complex gameplay or extended playtime might find it a bit lacking.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more.